All the best info from 2009

2009 SSGS Inter Area Team Championship  Moray G.C.

If you have yet to visit Moray then mark it down as a priority. It is a pure gem of a traditional Scottish links ranking right up there with the best of them. OK they have slightly noisy neighbours who at first provide novelty then some distraction. However once you factor in their predictable activity you can get down to fully appreciate Tom Morris's art. There is a St Andrews feel about the venue. The course starts within Lossie and heads out West along the coast.

Moray therefore provided a very fitting venue for our premier team championship. The distance North deterred some counties from making the trip. That is a pity. Seniors golf is the singular current growth area within the amateur game and seniors at club level do identify with the exploits of their local players at the higher level. Some sides arrived at Lossiemouth on a pre budgeted and funded basis, others were there through the enthusiasm of the players and others were simply not there.

We would plead with county associations to accord the team championship the status it surely merits and introduce the event to their planning when budgets are being prepared.

Anyway, enough of the politics. The unofficial bookies amongst the players had installed North East and South as joint favourites followed closely by Stirlingshire, Lothians and Perth & Kinross. Glasgow were well scrubbed up, and  managed by "The chosen one" Gus Lamond. They carried an air of confidence. Could Glasgow be a dark horse?

Competition day dawned with the sight of the already slick greens getting ironed! By the first tee time there was a brisk and increasing Sou'wester which turned the 323 yard first into 400+.Greens were smooth and true but the wind was a factor- even for four footers. Format is best five scores from six with the discarded score coming back into play in event of a tie.

Early starters Dunbartonshire and South set good target aggregates, South one ahead on 388. From the next groupings, Glasgow drew level with South and gained the lead thanks to the lower discard.

 Dunbartonshire

That score stayed in place with only the last three teams to register scores. Perth & Kinross and Stirlingshire were both a few shots adrift and it was hastily calculated that North East skipper John Johnston needed to get down in three more from a hanging lie at the back of the last green. Hazardous though, for beyond the pin it starts to gather towards the steep ledge at the front. Assured hands coaxed the ball down to three feet and a confident putt meant victory by two shots.

This led to an impromptu North Eastern jig by Sandy Pirie and Andrew Laird at the greenside.

 Winners North East

At the presentation fitting compliments were paid for the welcome provided by Moray and the condition of the course. Charles Stewart accepted the SSGS plaque marking the occasion and expressed the hope that the Society would return in the future. John Johnston thanked all involved and in particular Bill and Dorothy Crighton for another seamless administration exercise.

Comment of the week from Stirling's David Smith when another Tornado passed within a few feet "I'm sure that pilot's watch was five minutes slow"

Scores:

Winners and Gold Medallists

386  North East (George Paterson, Sandy Pirie, Mike Jenkins, Francis Clark, Andrew Laird and John Johnston)

Silver (after countback)

388 Glasgow (Jim McNally, Graham Cox, John Shand,John McDonald, Alistair McMillan, Peter Jamieson)

Bronze

388 South of Scotland (Ian Brotherston, George Rodaks, Ian Fraser, Tom Carson, Robbie Nairn, Gordon Doig)

Other Scores  389 Dunbarton, 393 Lothians, 395, Stirlingshire, 404 North, 406 Perth & Kinross, 423 Ayrshire

Leading Individual Scores

72  Mike Jenkins (North East) Ian Fraser (South) Ian Jeen (Dunbarton)

73 Ian Brotherston (South)

74 Alistair McMillan (Glasgow)

75 Andrew Wight (Lothians)

76 Peter Jamieson (Glasgow) Graham Cox (Glasgow) James Simpson (North)  Peter Kinloch (Dunbarton) Robert Jack (Lothians) Sandy Pirie (North East) George Paterson (North East)

77 Gordon MacDonald (Callander)

 

Team

SSGS Finals Day- The Blairgowrie Golf Club. OOM Finals Day was a fascinating prospect with any of the top six at the start of play in with a mathematical chance of succeeding Ian Hutcheon and Gordon MacDonald as title holder.

We are very grateful to The Blairgowrie Golf Club for their courtesy in hosting the annual shoot-out and they provided a Landsdowne course in prime condition plus glorious early autumn weather.

As the day progressed it became more and more likely that matchplay champion George Paterson would hold on to his OOM lead. Nearest challenger David Miller was not firing on all cylinders and defending title holder Gordon MacDonald was having to recover from two lost balls in the first three holes.

The day's low scores were posted by the in-form George Rodaks and the ever challenging Bob Stewart with fine 72s.

Unfortunately Ian Brotherston suffered a back injury before leaving home and had to withdraw. Other challengers Ian Hutcheon and Ian Taylor advised their disqualifications as they had played from the wrong tee at one hole. Ironically it was 40 yards behind the correct one but the Rules display no leniency in such situations.

And so George Paterson was able to complete his stroll in the sun with a tidy 76 and an eventual 45 point margin of victory.

In his acceptance speech George paid tribute to the spirit of friendship and competition created by the Society and thanked all concerned in a very successful season.

Euan Mordaunt represented SGU at Blairgowrie and talked of the close working relationship which had evolved between the respective bodies and wished the Society continued growth and success.

 

Scores from Blairgowrie  CSS 74

Bob Stewart Tulliallan 72
George Rodaks Moffat 72
Dave Downie Kirriemuir 75
David Smith Stirling 75
Eric Lindsay Blairgowrie 75
John Broadfoot Turnberry 75
George Paterson Northern 76
Keith Howie West Kilbride 77
Michael Jenkins Duff House Royal 77
Tony Stafford Dun Ochil 77
William Brown Strathaven 77
Alistair Fiddes Deeside 78
Gordon MacDonald Callander 78
John Johnston Lanark 79
David J Miller Kilmarnock Barassie 80
Graham Brown Royal Liverpool 80
Keith Bruce Edzell 80
Sandy Pirie Hazlehead 80
Alex Ritchie Bothwell Castle 81
Derek Murphy Kinross 81
Brian Christie Wilton 82
Jim Watt Edzell 82
Bill Methven Royal Aberdeen 84
Brian Smith Kilmacolm 84
Henry Anderson Glenbervie 84
Ian Hutcheon Monifieth dq
Ian Taylor Royal Burgess dq
Andrew Laird Deeside nr
Steve Ellis  Heritage of St Andrews nr
Ian Brotherston Dumfries and County wd

 

 

Scottish Seniors Match Play Championship

Sponsored by Abbeyfield Scotland Ltd.

Newmacher greens staff pulled out all of the the stops to give us a superb test throughout the week. This Dave Thomas course carries all the hallmarks associated with the architect- big subtle greens, a rich variety of trees and shrubs and man made lakes which certainly grab the attention on holes 1,9,10,13 and 17. Add to that a brisk Deeside draught and a mix of everything from bright sunshine to prolonged downpours and any champion is going to be a worthy one.

Following on from 36 holes qualifying on Monday and Tuesday, the top 32 were entered into an automatic draw. Main upset in the first round was the defeat of third placed qualifier Iain Stewart by Turnberry's John Broadfoot. Robert Gill had a very good victory over Andrew Campbell, a high finisher in the Scottish Seniors strokeplay at Panmure.

Round 2 saw the demise of President and Current Order of Merit Champion Gordon MacDonald at the hands of Ian Taylor. Robert Gill progressed against David Downie, another top-ten finisher at Panmure. Steve Ellis saw off the challenge of probable favourite Bob Stewart, Donnie McCart edged Derk Murphy in a match that went to the 21st. Defending Champion Ronnie Maclean outlasted local legend Sandy Pirie and Aberdeen Links Champion George Paterson ended the run of John Broadfoot. Robert Jack won a close encounter with Deeside's Andrew Laird and Barassie's David Miller was 2 under par in overcoming Brian Christie.

Highlight from the quarter finals was the continued form of David Miller- 4 under par in ending the run of the defending champ Ronnie Maclean. Ian Taylor, Steve Ellis and George Paterson progressed to join him in the semis.

The ongoing form of the players was a tribute to their fitness- good living lads, all of them. David Miller was again under par in ending the impressive run of Steve Ellis and George Paterson  edged out Royal Burgess's big hitting Ian Taylor.

Vice Captain John Johnston watched the semi finals and final and reports as follows: 

In the Semis - Steve Ellis lost by 4 and 3 to David Miller- he started 7,6 to be 2 down and got back to square  a couple of times but then gave it back. One down after 12 but hit trees left not far off the tee at 13, and then took 3 from edge of 14 and 15. In the other semi it was nip and tuck all the way through until Ian Taylor had a mis-cue at the 16th and then mis-judged the strong cross wind at the 17th to give George a winning advantage.

 Overall - the Friday was a very difficult weather day but George Paterson seemed to be best equipped and finished strongly from the 12th. His compact swing seemed to function pretty well in the wind and he holed out well also.

Report on the final is reproduced courtesy of our Press Baron Colin Farquharson

By COLIN FARQUHARSON
George Paterson thought he had achieved a career golf highlight when he won the Aberdeen Links championship - for all ages - earlier this summer.
But George topped that today at Newmachar Golf Club by adding the Scottish senior amateur match-play championship to his trophy collection.
The 57-year-old Northern Golf Club member was 19th of the 32 qualifiers from the 36-hole stroke-play eliminator at the start of the week but came into his own as a match-player after that.
George, a regular on the North-east Alliance winter circuit, climaxed three days of the cut-and-thrust play at which he excels by beating David J Miller (Kilmarnock Barassie), the No 4 seed, by 3 and 2 in the final over the Hawkshill course.
"It's been a great season for me," said George. "I've won the Aberdeen Links championship, gained my first Scotland senior cap - and now my first national golf title. Becoming old enough to play competitive senior golf has opened a new, and most successful, chapter in my golfing life."
Barassie-based Ayr United football fan Miller, 55, looked to be the favourite to take the championship in his rookie season as a senior when he wiped out Paterson's two-hole lead, gained with successes at the third and fifth, by winning the seventh, eighth and 11th where his opponent three-putted
But Patterson, who had holed a 15ft putt to halve the short ninth in par after taking two shots to get on the putting surface, responded to the pressure with another crucial putt. This one was from 12ft and dropped for a birdie to level matters again.
At that stage a sportingly well-fought final had all the makings of going the distance, maybe even into extra holes because there seemed little between the adversaries. But suddenly it was all over, only four holes later.
Paterson won the 13th, 15th and 16th with par figures to win by 3 and 2.
"I just couldn't buy a putt out there," said Miller. "I probably peaked on Thursday when I was several under par in winning my second round and quarter-final ties. In this morning's semi-final against Stephen Ellis - played in horrible weather of wind and rain - I won by 4 and 3 but I felt my rhythm was going and I never got it back in the final. I felt I played well to get to the final but didn't play nearly so well once I got there.
"And that's not to take anything away from George Paterson's performance. He holed some good putts, I didn't."
"Only" 55, David Miller looks certain to make his mark on the seniors' circuit over the next two or three years during which he has an age advantage.
George Paterson has another honour to look forward before the end of the season. He is in the Scotland team for the seniors' home internationals at Westport in Ireland from September 29 to October 1.
The Scottish senior men's amateur match-play championship, being played for only the second time, was sponsored by Abbeyfield Scotland, a charity for the elderly, providing housing support for the elderly. They were represented on the final day at Newmachar by Brian Highley and Elizabeth Miller.
Next year's championship will be staged at Kinross.

 

Quarter Final    Thurs 27 Semi Final           Fri 28   Final                    Fri 28
         
         
         
Stephen Ellis 1.30      
Robert Jack        
         
         
    Stephen Ellis 2&1 9.30  
    David J Miller 4&2    
         
         David J Miller 4 & 3
David J Miller 1.38      
Ronald Maclean        
         
         Final:
         George Paterson bt
         David J Miller
         3 and 2
         
Ian Taylor 1.46      
Donald McCart        George Paterson 2 & 1
         
         
    Ian Taylor 4&3 9.45  
    George Paterson 2&1    
         
         
George Paterson 1.54      
Robert Gill        
         
         
         





Final

 

North of Scotland Seniors Open

South of Scotland Committee Member and tour photographer George "Kodak" Rodaks was forced into a self portrait following his thrilling win from a strong field at Nairn.

George describes consistency as being the cornerstone of his success with a high percentage of greens in regulation. He did three putt the first green in his first round and again at the 6th, 16th and 17th in round 2. Birdies both days at the long 12th helped him keep his momentum and incurring only one penalty shot over the two days in difficult conditions was much tidier than the large majority of the field.

Bronze medal reulted in a three way tie between Iain Stewart, Bill Methven and Brian Smith

 

Full scores


CSS 74 75
GEORGE RODAKS MOFFAT 75 74 149
IAIN STEWART CURRAGH 78 72 150
BRIAN SMITH KILMACOLM 78 72 150
IAN BROTHERSTON DUMFRIES& CO 72 78 150
BOB STEWART TULLIALLAN 76 75 151
HUGH CLUNAS NAIRN DUNBAR 74 77 151
MICHAEL JENKINS DUFF HOUSE ROYAL 74 77 151
DEREK MURPHY KINROSS 77 75 152
JIM WATT EDZELL 78 75 153
JALIL AMAN GRANGEMOUTH 80 74 154
BILL METHVEN ROYAL ABERDEEN 78 76 154
ALISTAIR FIDDES DEESIDE 73 81 154
JOHN BROADFOOT TURNBERRY 78 77 155
COLIN CHRISTY KILMACOLM 78 77 155
KEITH BRUCE EDZELL 77 78 155
DONALD McCART SHERWOOD FOREST 75 80 155
SANDY PIRIE HAZLEHEAD 81 75 156
DAVID J MILLER BARASSIE 74 82 156
GLYN REES FLEETWOOD 82 75 157
SCOTT MACDONALD DUNFERMLINE 82 75 157
GRAEME MILLAR SWANSTON NEW 80 77 157
GORDON MACDONALD CALLANDER 79 78 157
STEPHEN ELLIS HERITAGE G S 77 80 157
DEREK SIM PANMURE 78 80 158
DAVID TAYLOR DUNFERMLINE 77 81 158
IAN HUTCHEON MONIFIETH 74 84 158
ERIC LINDSAY BLAIRGOWRIE 79 80 159
JAMES T JOHNSTON NORTHUMBERLAND 78 81 159
JIM ROY GRANGE 78 81 159
TONY McINTYRE LUNDIN 76 83 159
JOHN WESTWOOD MORAY 81 79 160
LINDSAY BLAIR GRANGEMOUTH 80 80 160
IAN JEEN MILNGAVIE 85 76 161
JOHN CUNNINGHAM FRASERBURGH 81 80 161
ALEX RITCHIE BOTHWELL CASTLE 80 82 162
IAN TAYLOR  ROYAL BURGESS 80 82 162
STUART POND WORKSOP 77 85 162
TREVOR BENNETT GREAT BARR 77 85 162
JIM PATON KIRKINTILLOCH 80 83 163
BRIAN CHRISTIE WILTON 78 85 163
JIM EMSLIE ROYAL ABERDEEN 86 78 164
ANDREW WILSON CLOBER 84 80 164
GRAHAM SOMERS BON ACCORD 76 88 164
DAVID NELSON ABOYNE 84 81 165
JOHN W JOHNSTON ROYAL ABERDEEN 83 82 165
BERT NICHOLSON ROYAL DORNOCH 83 83 166
ROBERT WHITESIDE MORECAMBE 82 84 166
FRASER SHARP BOAT OF GARTEN 80 86 166
BILLY MITCHELL EFFINGHAM 78 88 166
AIDAN GROUNDS FALKIRK TRYST 75 91 166
DENIS McQUADE GLENBERVIE 93 74 167
PATRICK TOMISSON NAIRN 88 79 167
ANDREW LAIRD DEESIDE 85 82 167
DAVID BUNKER NAIRN DUNBAR 85 83 168
JAMES INGRAM BOAT OF GARTEN 85 83 168
IAN PEDDIE TULLIALLAN 84 84 168
RONNIE GRANT CALEDONIAN 83 85 168
KEITH HOWIE WEST KILBRIDE 83 85 168
KEN THOMSON BRAMALL PARK 88 81 169
GEORGE PATERSON NORTHERN 88 81 169
DAVID A MILLAR NEW CLUB 84 86 170
ALAN NELSON BANCHORY 88 83 171
GORDON GRAY NEWMACHAR 83 88 171
JAMES GRAHAM DUDDINGSTON 82 89 171
NIGEL PARKER MURCAR 81 90 171
DOUGIE ADAMS DUNBAR 80 91 171
DENIS ALBUTT ROYAL DORNOCH 88 84 172
LINDSAY EDMOND HADDINGTON 83 89 172
JOHN RUSSELL MONARCH DUNES 86 87 173
BARRY MCDONALD STRATFORD ON AVON 84 90 174
MICHAEL MATHER BALLATER 82 92 174
LEE BUSHBY STRATHMORE 87 88 175
BRIAN HIGHLEY BUCHANAN CASTLE 83 92 175
PETER HIGGINS NEW CLUB 84 92 176
CHARLES BROWN FRILFORD HEATH 85 92 177
NORMAN WILLIAMSON BANCHORY 87 91 178
NEISH CHISHOLM KEMNAY 87 91 178
ROBBIE NAIRN LOCHMABEN 90 89 179
NORMAN MACWILLIAMS KINGUSSIE 94 86 180
JAMES SCOTT PETERCULTER 92 90 182
IAN KERR KILMACOLM 88 94 182
DOUG GREENHALGH NEW CLUB 96 89 185
JOHN HARRISON NEWMACHAR 96 93 189
JOHN KINSELLA BRAEMAR 95 96 191
RON MCDONALD MONIFIETH disq 85  
GEORGE CANT MONIFIETH disq 86  
COLIN TAINSH WEST KILBRIDE NR disq  
DOUGLAS BRODIE NAIRN DUNBAR 79 inj  
NIALL WATSON DUFF HOUSE ROYAL 89 NR  
DAVID WARREN NORTH BERWICK 90 NR  
TONY STAFFORD DUN OCHIL 81 NR  
COLIN MOIR WORKSOP 80 NR  
DOUG MITCHELL PANMURE 86 NR  
DOUGAL CHALMERS PANMURE NR NR  
DONALD MOODY BRAMFORD NR NR  
PAUL YORK ROYAL DORNOCH 82 NR  
BRIAN GRIEVE KING JAMES V1 80 NR  
BOB KERR UPHALL 88 NR  
DAVID LEIGHTON NORTHERN NR WD  

West of Scotland Seniors Open

Hamilton's greenkeepers pulled out all of the stops to give us a worthy test despite serious volumes of rain over the preceding week. The course played every inch of its 6600+ yards.

Round one saw the lead in the hands of Kilmacolm's Colin Christy with a sparkling 69 which gave him a two shot advantage over Gordon MacDonald and Kilmarnock Barassie's David Miller.  On the 72 mark were Ian Brotherston (Dumfries & County) , Graham Brown (Royal Liverpool), Sandy Pirie (Hazlehead), William Brown (Strathaven), SSGS Match Play Champion Ronnie Maclean (Hamilton) and David Gardner (Broomieknowe)

Overnight rain softened the course further for Friday and the yardage was probably equivalent to 7000+ at the coast.  Hoylake man Graham Brown produced a brilliant 69 to take the title by two shots from South Champ Ian Brotherston and by three from Gordon MacDonald.

Graham's success was founded on the strength of his driving and distance control. That combination set him up for eleven birdies over the two days. In fact, so good was the start to his second round that his 3 under par after 6 holes included two missed putts from within 10 feet. He later paid tribute to the support and encouragement from playing partners John Fraser and Eric Lindsay with wife Marnie, stating that this was something he found particularly rewarding about competing in SSGS events.

Graham has an interesting set of "golf clubs"...... Royal Liverpool (past captain), New Club, Royal and Ancient and Atlanta Athletic Club in USA. Additionally he is captain of The Watsonian Golf Club for whom he regularly turns out in the Dispatch Cup

Glenbervie's Denis McQuade continued his recent run of good form to win the bronze medal for best net return with a fine aggregate of 139.

Hamilton were presented with the SSGS plaque to recognise their three year tenure of the West event. 2010 sees us at Lanark.

 

Name Club Rd 1 Rd 2 Total

CSS 72 72
GRAHAM BROWN ROYAL LIVERPOOL 72 69 141
IAN BROTHERSTON DUMFRIES & COUNTY 72 71 143
GORDON MACDONALD CALLANDER 71 73 144
DAVID J MILLER BARASSIE 71 74 145
WILLIAM BROWN STRATHAVEN 72 74 146
COLIN CHRISTY KILMACOLM 69 77 146
TONY McINTYRE LUNDIN 78 70 148
HENRY ANDERSON GLENBERVIE 75 73 148
DEREK MURPHY KINROSS 73 75 148
DAVID IMRIE THORNTON 73 75 148
JIM WATT EDZELL 75 74 149
DENIS McQUADE GLENBERVIE 75 74 149
SANDY PIRIE HAZLEHEAD 72 77 149
JOHN JOHNSTON LANARK 76 74 150
KEN FORREST LENZIE 76 74 150
ERIC LINDSAY BLAIRGOWRIE 76 74 150
JOHN FRASER ROYAL BURGESS 73 77 150
GLYN REES FLEETWOOD 73 77 150
BILL METHVEN ROYAL ABERDEEN 78 73 151
JAMES KINLOCH CARDROSS 74 77 151
DAVID GARDNER BROOMIEKNOWE 72 79 151
HARRY MILLIGAN HAMILTON 80 72 152
JOHN W JOHNSTON ROYAL ABERDEEN 77 75 152
BOB STEWART TULLIALLAN 77 75 152
LINDSAY BLAIR GRANGEMOUTH 77 75 152
BRIAN SMITH KILMACOLM 76 76 152
JAMES EMSLIE ROYAL ABERDEEN 75 77 152
RONNIE MACLEAN HAMILTON 72 80 152
KEITH BRUCE EDZELL 76 77 153
COLIN McLACHLAN GLENBERVIE 76 77 153
PETER JAMIESON CATHKIN BRAES 75 78 153
JAMES PATON KIRKINTILLOCH 78 76 154
ALISTAIR FIDDES DEESIDE 76 78 154
ANTHONY CLARK DUMFRIES & COUNTY 76 78 154
BILL ERSKINE KILSYTH & LENNOX 80 75 155
GORDON THOMSON BEARSDEN 73 82 155
JOHN RUSSELL MONARCH DUNES 79 77 156
MARSHALL DOUGLAS THORNHILL 79 77 156
JAMES T JOHNSTON NORTHUMBERLAND 78 78 156
SCOTT MACDONALD DUNFERMLINE 80 77 157
BOB KERR UPHALL 80 77 157
DAVID SMITH STIRLING 79 78 157
RICHARD T GRAY COWGLEN 77 80 157
IAN GOURLAY STRATHAVEN 79 79 158
ALEX RITCHIE BOTHWELL CASTLE 79 79 158
HARRY DOUTHWAITE CARDROSS 76 82 158
BRIAN HIGHLEY BUCHANAN CASTLE 80 79 159
IAN PEDDIE TULLIALLAN 80 79 159
BRIAN CHRISTIE WILTON 80 79 159
BERT NICHOLSON ROYAL DORNOCH 78 81 159
JIM BUNTING BALLOCHMYLE 81 79 160
JOHN BROADFOOT TURNBERRY 79 81 160
RONALD NELSON POWFOOT 79 81 160
JOHN DUFF MORTONHALL 75 85 160
COLIN MOIR WORKSOP 83 78 161
PETER KINLOCH CARDROSS 82 79 161
KEN THOMSON BRAMALL PARK 81 80 161
RUSSELL CAMPBELL STIRLING 81 80 161
ALAN NELSON BANCHORY 81 80 161
LINDSAY EDMOND HADDINGTON 77 84 161
FRASER McCATHIE HELENSBURGH 83 79 162
HENRY THOMPSON IRVINE 83 79 162
PHIL COSTELLO HIRSEL 81 81 162
SCOTT BRADY BURNTISLAND 81 81 162
DEREK SIM PANMURE 80 82 162
KEITH HOWIE WEST KILBRIDE 80 82 162
LEE BUSHBY STRATHMORE 84 79 163
BRIAN HALBERT CALLANDER 81 82 163
SANDY COWIE HILTON PARK 84 80 164
ROBBIE NAIRN LOCHMABEN 84 80 164
COLIN TAINSH WEST KILBRIDE 84 80 164
RONNIE GRANT CALEDONIAN 83 81 164
IAN DICKSON LUNDIN 81 83 164
SANDY QUINN STIRLING 80 84 164
HUGH WATERS BOTHWELL CASTLE 83 82 165
DOMINIC McLAUGHLIN CROW WOOD 81 84 165
MICHAEL MATHER  BALLATER 89 77 166
CHARLES BROWN FRILFORTH HEATH 82 84 166
TOM CARSON LOCKERBIE 81 85 166
DAVID HALKERSTON NEW CLUB 81 85 166
GORDON GRAHAM IRVINE 80 86 166
ALEC INGRAM NEW CLUB 83 84 167
NORMAN WILLIAMSON BANCHORY 80 87 167
NEISH CHISHOLM KEMNAY 85 83 168
DAVID LAIRD EAST RENFREWSHIRE 82 86 168
RAY BARTON ALLOA 87 83 170
FRASER SHARP BOAT OF GARTEN 85 86 171
NEIL MACDONALD GLENBERVIE 82 89 171
IAN SMITH EAST KILBRIDE 85 88 173
TOM NICOL ELDERSLIE 88 86 174
BOB ALEXANDER HILTON PARK 86 88 174
PETER STICKLEY SAFETY BEACH 87 89 176
IAN DONALDSON KILLIN 86 97 183
JIM GRAHAM CLOBER disq 73  
WILSON MORTON DUNBAR disq 77  
JIM TRAYNOR HILTON PARK NR 89  
PHIL MAWHOOD TULLIALLAN 83 NR  
DOUGIE GREENHALGH NEW CLUB 87 NR  
JALIL AMAN GRANGEMOUTH disq NR  
CLIVE BOURNE THORNHILL 81 NR  
IAN JEEN MILNGAVIE 78 NR  
JOHNSTON MACKIE GLENEARN NS NS  
JIM ROY GRANGE NR NS  
ANDREW WIGHT GLENCOURSE NS NS  
GEORGE RODAKS MOFFAT NR WD  
STEPHEN ELLIS HERITAGE G S 83 WD  
DAVID MILLAR NEW CLUB inj.
 

 

 

 

The County's Top Man retains his South of Scotland Title

Ian Brotherston used his power judiciously to compile a first round 66 which gave him a one stroke halfway lead from joint SSGS Secretary Jim Kinloch and by two from Royal Liverpool's Graham Brown. He was one of the few able to knock it on in two at the par five 7th. one of three eagle chances.

Hovering on 69s were Stirling Winner Ian Taylor and David Fulton from Castle Douglas.

The weather was brilliant and the course set up beatifully so as to reward accurate and positive play. On the other hand careless tee shots and clumsy approaches were duly punished by a combination of intrusive trees, sneaky semi-rough and some testing pin placings.

Day two saw the leader carefully avoid trouble and his second round 70 for an aggregate of 136 was never seriously tested. Graham Brown added a 72 to his 68 for second place and Ian Taylor maintained his good recent form for 3rd on 141. South Region was well represented with Maitland Pollock, Alistair Harkness and Tony Clark all joining ian Brotherston in the top ten.

Thanks are due to the County for truly excellent hospitality, a course prepared to a cvery high standard, and for the volunteer starters. Food and bar service were from the top drawer.  Thanks again to Bill and Dorothy for their seamless administration. It is certainly not as easy as they make it look!  Onwards to Hamilton.

South of Scotland Open



Dumfries & County GC 9th & 10th July 2009


Name Club Rd 1 Rd 2 Total

CSS 69 69
IAN BROTHERSTON DUMFRIES & CO. 66 70 136
GRAHAM BROWN ROYAL LIVERPOOL 68 72 140
IAN TAYLOR ROYAL BURGESS 69 72 141
MAITLAND POLLOCK LOCHMABEN 72 70 142
JOHN W JOHNSTON ROYAL ABERDEEN 71 71 142
JOHN FRASER ROYAL BURGESS 71 71 142
ALISTAIR HARKNESS SOUTHERNESS 71 71 142
ANTHONY CLARK DUMFRIES & CO 70 72 142
ADRIAN DONKERSLEY GERRARDS CROSS 72 71 143
DAVID J MILLER BARASSIE 71 72 143
DAVID GARDNER BROOMIEKNOWE 70 73 143
PETER JAMIESON CATHKIN BRAES 76 68 144
BOB STEWART TULLIALLAN 71 73 144
JIM KINLOCH CARDROSS 67 77 144
JOHN BROADFOOT TURNBERRY 78 67 145
RONNIE MACLEAN HAMILTON 74 71 145
STEPHEN ELLIS HERITAGE G.S. 72 73 145
KEITH McALLISTER SOUTH SHIELDS 72 73 145
MICHAEL CURRIE THE GLEN 70 75 145
DAVIE FULTON DUMFRIES & COUNTY 69 76 145
JOHN JOHNSTON LANARK 76 70 146
GORDON THOMSON BEARSDEN 74 72 146
LINDSAY BLAIR GRANGEMOUTH 74 72 146
NORMAN CAMERON PORTERS PARK 73 73 146
SANDY PIRIE HAZLEHEAD 72 74 146
JOHN ROBERTS LANCASTER 72 74 146
BOB HUMBLE KILSPINDIE 71 75 146
GORDON MACDONALD CALLANDER 70 76 146
GEORGE RODAKS MOFFAT 76 71 147
DEREK MURPHY KINROSS 76 71 147
JIM McARTHUR NEW CLUB 76 71 147
DAVID BUNKER NAIRN DUNBAR 74 73 147
GEORGE PATERSON NORTHERN 74 73 147
GEORGE BLAIR HADDINGTON 73 74 147
GEORGE PAYNE PRESTBURY 72 75 147
GLEN BALLANTYNE  WILLIAMWOOD 71 76 147
BOB EDGAR BLACKPOOL N S  75 73 148
BRIAN SMITH KILMACOLM 74 74 148
KEITH ROSS BEITH 72 76 148
RICHARD GRAY COWGLEN 78 71 149
STUART POND WORKSOP 77 72 149
DONNIE LINDSAY WINDYHILL 77 72 149
BILL McINTYRE HARPENDEN 75 74 149
JIM WATT EDZELL 73 76 149
ALISTAIR FIDDES DEESIDE 72 77 149
PATRICK TOMISSON NAIRN   70 79 149
COLIN MOIR WORKSOP 79 71 150
WILLIAM ERSKINE KILSYTH LENNOX 78 72 150
GRAEME MILLAR SWANSTON NEW 76 74 150
TREVOR BENNETT GREAT BARR 74 76 150
DEREK SIM PANMURE 79 72 151
WILLIAM BROWN STRATHAVEN 78 73 151
GORDON DOIG SOUTHERNESS 77 74 151
SANDY QUINN STIRLING 74 77 151
KEN FORREST LENZIE 73 78 151
BRIAN GRIEVE KING JAMES V1 78 74 152
KEITH HOWIE WEST KILBRIDE 77 75 152
JOHN McDONALD COWGLEN 77 75 152
IAN JEEN MILNGAVIE 77 75 152
DAVID J SMITH STIRLING 76 76 152
BRIAN CHRISTIE WILTON 72 80 152
DONALD McCART SHERWOOD FOREST 71 81 152
GLYN REES FLEETWOOD 80 73 153
RONALD NELSON POWFOOT 79 74 153
JOHN RUSSELL MONARCH DUNES 76 77 153
BRIAN HIGHLEY BUCHANAN CASTLE 75 78 153
KEN RUSSELL WIGTOWN&BLADEN'H 80 74 154
JAMES PATON KIRKINTILLOCH 78 76 154
RONNIE McLELLAN TURNBERRY 78 76 154
PETER KINLOCH CARDROSS 76 78 154
LINDSAY EDMOND HADDINGTON 80 75 155
DENIS McQUADE GLENBERVIE 77 78 155
TOM NICOL ELDERSLIE 82 74 156
ALAN NELSON BANCHORY 75 81 156
CLIVE BOURNE THORNHILL 78 79 157
IAN DICKSON LUNDIN 78 79 157
JIM BUNTING BALLOCHMYLE 82 76 158
DAVID MACLEAN HAMILTON 80 78 158
TOM CARSON LOCKERBIE 77 82 159
ROBBIE NAIRN LOCHMABEN 82 78 160
ERIC LINDSAY BLAIRGOWRIE 76 85 161
MAURICE SHIELDS WINDYHILL 82 80 162
IAN KERR KILMACOLM 81 82 163
FRASER SHARP BOAT OF GARTEN 75 89 164
MURRAY REID DUMFRIES & CO. 83 82 165
ROGER REES EDEN 82 83 165
IAN DONALDSON KILLIN 79 86 165
ANGUS MARTIN SOUTHERNESS 84 84 168
PHIL COSTELLO HIRSEL 88 81 169
MICHAEL MATHER BALLATER 86 85 171
DREW WILSON CLOBER 86 85 171
VINCE ADAMS EXETER 85 86 171
NEISH CHISHOLM KEMNAY 88 85 173
NORMAN WILLIAMSON BANCHORY 88 85 173
MARK LIRONI CATHKIN BRAES NR 80  
ROBERT KERR UPHALL ret inj inj  
HARRY MILLIGAN HAMILTON NR WD  

 

 

 

 

 

Three in a row for the Monifieth Maestro

During his acceptance speech following conference of honorary membership of SSGS, Ian Hutcheon stated that, either he was getting less competitive, or the course was 10 shots harder. There was however a steely glint which brought to mind the famous Glaswegian expression "Aye, right!"

True to form he pulled together a trademark second round 68 which left him clear at the top for the third consecutive year. Getting Ian to talk about his round is akin to drawing teeth without the anaesthetic but he was partnered by El Presidente who describes the round as superbly controlled. Only bogey was when a bad kick off the right hand side of the 6th left him with an impeded backswing. That was counteracted by "easy birdies" at 1,8,17 and 18.  Highlight shot was from the downslope on the bank at the front of the par three 11th which Ian caressed up to 2 feet to save par.

Fine performance in second place by Tony McIntyre (Lundin) whose second round 71 was "best of the rest."  Picking up points on 147 were a resurgent David Smith (Stirling), whose first round 72 was remarkable for having started 6,5, and David Miller (Barassie) who demonstrated his liking for the course with another fine performance. On 148 were regulars Jim Watt and George Paterson. George, the new Aberdeen Links Champion, was left to regret a bucket and spade session in the bunkers at the18th in round one. Jim with typical good humour ignored his partners' attempts to flag down a passing ice cream van and buy him a 66!!

 

Scoreboard

Monifieth East of Scotland Open


25&26 June 2009 CSS 75 73
IAN HUTCHEON MONIFIETH 76 68 144
TONY McINTYRE LUNDIN 75 71 146
DAVID J MILLER BARASSIE 74 73 147
DAVID SMITH STIRLING 72 75 147
JIM WATT EDZELL 74 74 148
GEORGE PATERSON NORTHERN 74 74 148
ALEX RITCHIE BOTHWELL CASTLE 78 72 150
ERIC LINDSAY BLAIRGOWRIE 78 72 150
ROBERT THOMSON ST. ANDREWS 75 75 150
RICHARD T GRAY COWGLEN 73 77 150
HENRY ANDERSON GLENBERVIE 77 74 151
IAN JEEN MILNGAVIE 78 74 152
AIDEN GROUNDS FALKIRK TRYST 81 72 153
SANDY PIRIE HAZLEHEAD 77 76 153
SANDY FAIRWEATHER CALEDONIA CARNOUSTIE 76 77 153
JOHN FRASER ROYAL BURGESS 81 73 154
PETER JAMIESON CATHKIN BRAES 77 77 154
DAVID DOWNIE KIRRIEMUIR 76 78 154
WILLIAM ERSKINE KILSYTH LENNOX 80 75 155
BOB STEWART TULLIALLAN 79 76 155
DEREK MURPHY KINROSS 79 76 155
DOUGAL CHALMERS PANMURE 79 76 155
COLIN MOIR WORKSOP 78 77 155
IAN STEWART CURRAGH 79 77 156
GEORGE RODAKS MOFFAT 79 77 156
JALIL AMAN GRANGEMOUTH 77 79 156
GORDON MACDONALD CALLANDER 76 80 156
STEPHEN ELLIS HERITAGE G S 83 74 157
MARSHALL DOUGLAS THORNHILL 80 77 157
GEORGE BLAIR HADDINGTON 79 78 157
JOHN JOHNSTON LANARK 79 78 157
MICHAEL JENKINS DUFF HOUSE ROYAL 79 78 157
ANDREW LAIRD DEESIDE 78 79 157
DAVID IMRIE THORNTON 78 79 157
DEREK SIM PANMURE 79 79 158
BRIAN SMITH KILMACOLM 79 79 158
IAN GOURLAY STRATHAVEN 78 80 158
RONNIE McLELLAN TURNBERRY 83 76 159
JIM KINLOCH CARDROSS 79 80 159
SCOTT BRADY BURNTISLAND 82 78 160
TONY STAFFORD GLENEAGLES DUN OCHIL 82 78 160
FRED HUTCHEON MONIFIETH 81 79 160
JOHN McDONALD COWGLEN 81 79 160
BILL METHVEN ROYAL ABERDEEN 80 80 160
JOHN W JOHNSTON ROYAL ABERDEEN 76 84 160
DREW WILSON CLOBER 85 76 161
RON McDONALD MONIFIETH 83 78 161
DAVID A MILLAR NEW CLUB 79 82 161
ALISTAIR FIDDES DEESIDE 86 76 162
JOHN RUSSELL MONARCH DUNES 86 76 162
JOHN SIM DUFF HOUSE ROYAL 85 77 162
RICHARD GOODALE ABERDOUR 82 81 163
WILSON MORTON DUNBAR 80 83 163
JIM CAMPBELL PANMURE 78 85 163
DAVID LEIGHTON NORTHERN 82 82 164
GRAHAM SOMERS BON-ACCORD 82 82 164
JIM EMSLIE ROYAL ABERDEEN 78 86 164
GORDON THOMSON BEARSDEN 88 77 165
TOM CARSON LOCKERBIE 85 80 165
MICHAEL NIVEN ALLOA 82 83 165
DENIS ALBUTT ROYAL DORNOCH 87 79 166
JIM ROY GRANGE 85 81 166
LEE BUSHBY STRATHMORE 84 82 166
TREVOR BENNET GREAT BARR 84 82 166
JAMES INGRAM BOAT OF GARTEN 84 82 166
TIM HARTNETT ST ANDREWS 82 84 166
BERT NICHOLSON ROYAL DORNOCH 82 84 166
GORDON GRAY NEWMACHAR 81 85 166
JOHN BROADFOOT TURNBERRY 86 81 167
DAVID NELSON ABOYNE 83 84 167
DENIS MCQUADE GLENBERVIE 83 84 167
PETER KINLOCH CARDROSS 87 81 168
DAVID GARDNER BROOMIEKNOWE 82 86 168
ALAN NELSON BANCHORY 86 83 169
CHARLES D STEWART MORAY 90 80 170
STEVE HILLS MONIFIETH 87 83 170
BRIAN HIGHLEY BUCHANAN CASTLE 87 83 170
RICHARD L GRAY LANARK 86 84 170
FRASER SHARP BOAT OF GARTEN 86 84 170
IAN PEDDIE TULLIALLAN 84 86 170
RONNIE GRANT CALEDONIAN 88 83 171
MALCOLM SIM GRANGE 87 84 171
BRIAN INGLIS ARCHERFIELD 86 85 171
SANDY QUINN STIRLING 85 86 171
LINDSAY EDMOND HADDINGTON 85 86 171
NORMAN WILLIAMSON BANCHORY 87 85 172
PETER STICKLEY SAFETY BEACH 87 85 172
NEISH CHISHOLM KEMNAY 87 86 173
GEORGE CANT MONIFIETH 85 89 174
PHIL MAWHOOD TULLIALLAN 86 89 175
JAMES SCOTT PETERCULTER 89 87 176
ANGUS MARTIN SOUTHERNESS 88 88 176
MICHAEL MATHER BALLATER 94 84 178
NEIL MACDONALD GLENBERVIE 87 91 178
TOM GRAY LANARK 94 85 179
PETER HIGGINS NEW CLUB 92 88 180
NIGEL PARKER MURCAR 94 87 181
ALEC INGRAM NEW CLUB 92 89 181
JOHNSTON MACKIE GLENEARN 90 91 181
PHILIP COSTELLO HIRSEL 82 99 181
DOUGIE ADAMS DUNBAR 93 89 182
JOHN HARRISON NEWMACHAR 90 94 184
IAN DONALDSON KILLIN 92 93 185
LES FOWLER ROYAL ABERDEEN NR 91 0
KEITH HOWIE WEST KILBRIDE 79 WD 0
GORDON DOIG SOUTHERNESS 80 WD 0
IAN BROTHERSTON DUMFRIES & CO. ret inj NS 0
ANDREW McGREGOR BLAIRGOWRIE NS
0
RON WOODLEY DUNDAS PARK 94 NS 0
ALISTAIR THOMSON KIRKCALDY 87 NR 0
KEN FORREST LENZIE 85 NR 0
MARK LIRONI CATHKIN BRAES 83 NR 0
IAN KERR KILMACOLM 90 NR 0
DAVID MACLEAN HAMILTON NR NR 0
BRIAN CHRISTIE WILTON 81 NR 0

 

Gold Medal   Ian Hutcheon

Brinze Medal  David Smith

 

 

Heads or Tails- Taylor Heads

When asked about his prospects for Stirling, Ian Taylor was heard to say it was a toss up as to whioh swing turned up. As it happened his "A" swing was very much in evidence as his four under par aggregate of 140 was good enough for a two shot victory. His Thursday round was pretty consistent with birides at 5 and 17 balanced by bogeys at 14 and 15- the only deviations from par. Friday started with a birdie, par at 2 and then a crucial bogey at 3 where he hit 2 iron tee shot into an unplayable lie in the bush up the left. After taking his penalty drop he pulled his approach and then managed to get up and down. Ian then holed a good 25 footer at 4 for a par, then drive and 6 iron at the par five 5th to 10 feet above the hole. He managed to coax his swinging downhill putt in for an eagle, followed by a 30 footer on next green for a 2, so then 3 under, which he held together mainly hitting greens but made two crucial up and ins at 15 and 17 for pars, then again at last for closing birdie. Ian commented "This is only the second 36 hole open event I have won in my life!! Last one the Linlithgow open in 1980!!"  The prodigious hitter's other claim to fame was when he held the title of world haggis hurling champion in the 1970s (honest!)

CSS Both days 72

 

Player Club        Rd 1 Rd 2 Total
Ian Taylor Royal Burgess 72 68 140
Brian Smith Kilmacolm 72 70 142
Eric Lindsay Blairgowrie 71 71 142
David J Miller Barrassie 75 69 144
Ian Brotherstone Dumfries & Co 70 75 145
Gordon MacDonald Callander 73 73 146
Ronnie Maclean Hamilton 72 75 147
Keith Bruce Edzell 72 75 147
Donald McCart Sherwood Forest 73 75 148
Ian Jeen Milngavie 75 74 149
Derek Murphy Kinross 74 75 149
William Brown Strathaven 78 72 150
David Gardner Broomieknowe 77 73 150
Jim Watt Edzell 76 74 150
Graeme Millar Swanston New 75 75 150
Alan MacNaught Colchester 78 73 151
Gordon Brown Vale of Leven 74 77 151
Michael Jenkins Duff House Royal 74 77 151
Alex Ritchie Bothwell Castle 74 77 151
Bob Edgar Blackpool N S 73 78 151
Scott MacDonald Dunfermline 73 78 151
Alan Ferguson Drumpellier 77 75 152
Denis McQuade Glenbervie 76 76 152
John W Johnston Royal Aberdeen 76 76 152
Stephen Ellis Heritage G S 79 74 153
Jalil Aman Grangemouth 78 75 153
John Broadfoot Turnberry 78 75 153
Ronnie McLellan Turnberry 78 75 153
David Smith Stirling 77 76 153
John McDonald Cowglen 77 76 153
Jim McArthur New Club 77 76 153
George Rodaks Moffat 76 77 153
Bob Stewart Tulliallan 75 78 153
Henry Anderson Glenbervie 75 78 153
Richard Gray Cowglen 78 76 154
Colin Milne Pitlochry 77 77 154
Aiden Grounds Falkirk Tryst 76 78 154
Colin Christy Kilmacolm 76 78 154
Colin Halcrow Windyhill 76 78 154
David Imrie Thornton 75 79 154
Michael Currie The Glen 75 79 154
Partick Tomisson Nairn 78 77 155
Sandy Pirie Hazlehead 77 78 155
Scott Brady Burntisland 76 79 155
Ken Forrest Lenzie 81 75 156
Bob Humble Kilspindie 78 78 156
Russell Campbell Stirling 74 82 156
David Bunker Nairn Dunbar 78 79 157
Keith McAllister South Shields 78 79 157
David Millar New Club 77 80 157
Billy Wallace Strathaven 80 78 158
Iain Stewart Curragh 79 79 158
Drew Wilson Clober 77 81 158
Ken Thomson Brammal Park 82 77 159
John Russell Morarch Dunes 81 78 159
Tony McIntyre Lundin 80 79 159
Gordon Thomson Bearsden 78 81 159
Brian Halbert Callander 76 83 159
Robert Kerr Uphalll 81 79 160
George Blair Haddington 79 81 160
Graham Brown Royal Liverpool 78 82 160
John Sim Duff House Royal 77 83 160
Brian Bingham Haggs Castle 81 80 161
Colin Moir Worksop 81 80 161
David Leighton Northern 80 81 161
Lee Bushby Strathmore 80 81 161
George Kay Alloa 78 83 161
David Warren North Berwick 84 78 162
Phil Costello Hirsel 87 76 163
Ronald Nelson Powfoot 84 79 163
Trevor Bennett Great Barr 82 81 163
Peter Kinloch Cardross 80 83 163
Keith Howie West Kilbride 79 84 163
Michael Niven Alloa 87 77 164
John Cunningham Fraserburgh 86 78 164
Ken Lumsden Glenbervie 84 80 164
Alan Nelson Banchory 84 80 164
Brian Highley Buchanan Castle 82 82 164
James Paton Kirkintilloch 80 84 164
Colin McLachlan Glenbervie 86 79 165
James Kinloch Cardross 84 81 165
Sandy Cowie Hilton Park 84 82 166
Neish Chisholm Kemnay 86 81 167
Gordon Gray Newmachar 83 84 167
David Halkerston New Club 83 84 167
Johnston Mackie Glenearn 82 85 167
Charles Brown Frilford Heath 81 86 167
Les Fowler Royal Aberdeen 81 86 167
Alistair Thomson Kirkcaldy 87 81 168
Fraser Sharp Boat of Garten 86 82 168
Ray Barton Alloa 85 83 168
Ron McDonald Monifieth 83 85 168
Gordon Graham Irvine 82 86 168
Brian Christie Wilton 82 86 168
Ian Smith East Kilbride 82 88 170
David MacLean Hamilton 89 82 171
Robbie Nairn Lochmaben 87 84 171
Tom Carson Lockerbie 83 88 171
Ian Donaldson Killin 89 83 172
Jim Traynor Hilton Park 84 88 172
David Laird East Renfrewshire 85 88 173
Neil MacDonald Glenbervie 85 89 174
Ian Kerr Kilmacolm 85 90 175
Tom Nicol Elderslie 89 87 176
David Nelson Aboyne 89 89 178
Peter Stickley Safety Beach 90 89 179
Michael Hill Douglas Park 92 90 182
Ken Goodwin Glenbervie inj 79  
Fraser McCathie Helensborough 92 inj  
George Taylor Royal Burgess 79 NR  
Lindsay Edmond Haddington 84 NR  
Harry Milligan Hamilton 82 NR  
Ian Dickson Lundin 76 WD  
George Paterson Northern 79 WD  
Kevin Mullins New Club inj WD  
George Cant Monifieth 93 WD  

 

 

 David Lane (Goring and Streatley) is the 2009 Scottish Seniors Amateur Champion after a fascinating three days golf at Panmure. Over a course prepared to absolutely prime condition, momentum moved back and forth at regular intervals. Day one saw Ian Hutcheon cruise to the front with a brilliant 67. David Lane was in touch with a fine 70 for second place. Joint third on the 73 mark were members Andrew Wight, Donnie McCart and Robert Gill. The evergreen Sandy Pirie was in touch on 75. Wednesday looked to be treading a predictable path until Ian Hutcheon fell foul of some of Panmure's hidden perils and dropped a series of shots over the last five holes. This allowed both David lane and John Fraser to move a stroke clear, John after an excellent 68, best of the day and second best of the tournament. Gordon MacDonald moved into contention with a very good 71 which included a lost ball at the par three 9th. Far travelled Robert Vallis (Bermuda) showed his mettle with a great 70 to tie third place. It was all set up for a very interesting final round. Panmure was in condition unequalled in anyone's memory of this championship. Slick, fair, but beware! was the message. The wind had moved from across the majority of holes to straight up and down. Combatants needed to stay in touch over the first 12 holes and then cope with the tricky downwind conditions for the last 6. Meanwhile back at the clubhouse John Johnston and David Downie had moved through the field with final round 73s, Sandy Pirie followed up on his high finish at Gailes with a steady 76 for 226 and a tie for 8th, one better than George Payne. Andrew Campbell (Kinross) posted a final round 72 which had him handily placed should there be any slip up by the leaders. So to the conclusion. John Fraser and Robert Vallis remained in touch but had fallen a couple of shots behind. "Hutch" and David Lane tied with five to go. Ian found tricky lies from off the putting surface at 14,15 and 16 and a run of par, bogey, bogey opened the door to the ultra consistent approach of the Goring and Streatley man. Five very solid pars were good enough for victory by two shots. Remarkable in itself is the fact that 1st and 2nd plus Sandy Pirie tied 8th, are all over 65. Fine wines indeed! Scores from Panmure

CSS Rd 1 73 Rd 2 73 Rd 3 73

1 LANE, David (65+) Goring & Streatley 70 75 74 219

2 HUTCHEON, Ian (65+) Monifieth 67 79 75 221

T3 CAMPBELL, Andrew Kinross 75 76 72 223

T3 FRASER, John Royal Burgess 78 68 77 223

T5 DOWNIE, David Kirriemuir 77 74 73 224

T5 BAKER, Stephen Woodside 74 74 76 224

T5 VALLIS, Robert Bermuda 76 70 78 224

T8 JOHNSTON, John Royal Aberdeen 78 75 73 226

T8 PIRIE, Alexande (65+) Hazlehead 75 75 76 226

T8 SLATER, Philip Sandiway 75 74 77 226

T11 PAYNE, George Prestbury 75 76 76 227

T11 MACDONALD, Gordon Callander 76 71 80 227

13 CRELLIN, Paul Prenton 78 77 73 228

T14 MACBRYDE, Keith Stone 74 80 75 229

T14 DONKERSLEY, Adrian Gerrards Cross 77 76 76 229

T14 REES, Glyn Fleetwoood 74 77 78 229

T14 FERGUSON, Alan Drumpellier 77 74 78 229

T14 PATERSON, George Northern 76 73 80 229

T19 HUGHES, Glyn Church Stretton 74 81 75 230

T19 WIGHT, Andrew Glencorse 73 80 77 230

T19 KING, Geoffrey West Essex 81 72 77 230

T19 MACDONALD, Scott Dunfermline 78 75 77 230

T19 PATTERSON, Tony Sunningdale 76 77 77 230

T19 COWE, Ralph Kelso 76 77 77 230

T19 BLACK, John Scotscraig 74 76 80 230

T26 STEWART, Robert Tulliallan 77 76 78 231

T26 BALDWIN, John Sunningdale 77 74 80 231

28 JACK, Robert Liberton 78 74 80 232

T29 CAMPBELL, Richard Kinross 79 76 78 233

T29 MACINTYRE, Bill Harpenden 77 78 78 233

T29 TOLLY, Rich USA 80 75 78 233

T29 GROUNDS, Aidan Falkirk Tryst 75 79 79 233

T29 TEMPLE, Martyn USA 76 76 81 233

T29 MCCART, Donald Sherwood Forest 73 78 82 233

T29 CLARK, Francis Royal Aberdeen 75 75 83 233

T36 WATT, Jim Edzell 75 79 80 234

T36 BROWN, William Strathaven 77 75 82 234

38 SWENSON, Norma USA 77 77 81 235

T39 HUBBARD, Jonathan Sunningdale 80 74 82 236

T39 GILL, Robert Gerrards Cross 73 79 84 236

T41 WALLACE, Robert Crosland Heath 78 76 83 237

T41 GRIFFITHS, Basil Llanymynech 77 75 85 237

43 HALCROW, Colin Windyhill 75 79 85 239

44 BRETT, Alistair Northumberland 81 74 86 251

 

Glasgow Gailes provided a stern test for the competitors with the natural perils of gorse and heather supplemented by stong and variable winds. The top two from last year's order of merit quickly re-joined battle with Bob Stewart coming out on top and SSGS Captain Gordon MacDonald chasing him home for second place. Close up third was John Fraser Special mention for Sandy Pirie, in there mixing it with the nippers throughout two rough days. Well done also the South of Scotland contingent. Our smallest region by number had three players in the top 20 CSS Round 1 74 Css Round 2 75 (Reduction Only) Player Club Rd 1 Rd 2 Bob Stewart Tulliallan 71 73 Gordon MacDonaldCallander 74 73 John Fraser Royal Burgess 72 76 Stuart Pond Worksop 77 74 Colin Christy Kilmacolm 76 75 Sandy Pirie Hazlehead 75 76 David Dickson Lochmaben 74 78 William Brown Strathaven 74 79 George Paterson Northern 73 80 Donald McCart Sherwood Forest 76 78 Brian Bingham Haggs Castle 72 82 Derek Murphy Kinross 78 77 Ken Russell Wigton & Blad 78 77 William Moore Ravenspark 78 77 George Rodaks Moffat 76 79 Tony Stafford Dun Ochil Gle 79 77 Ronnie MacLean Hamilton 77 79 Bill MacIntyre Harpenden 81 76 John Broadfoot Turnberry 81 76 Henry Anderson Glenbervie 78 79 Michael Currie Glen 78 79 William Erskine Kilsyth Lennox 78 79 Andrew Laird Deeside 77 80 Mark Lironi Kathkin Braes 76 81 Glyn Rees Fleetwood 74 83 Derek Sim Panmure 81 77 John Duff Mortonhall 80 78 Brian Smith Kilmacolm 79 79 Ian Taylor Royal Burgess 79 79 Ian Brotherston Dumfries & cty 78 80 Gordon Brown Vale of Leven 79 80 Stephen Ellis Heritage 78 81 Keith McAllisterSouth Shields 77 82 Alan McEwan Hamilton 82 78 Allistair RaphaelCanterbury 81 79 David Smith Stirling 79 81 Gordon Thomson Bearsden 79 81 James Haddow Darwen 78 82 Graeme Millar Swanston New 76 84 Jim Paton Kirkintilloch 83 78 Keith Bruce Edzell 82 79 Ian Cumming Eastwood 80 81 Jim Graham Clober 80 81 Wilson Morton Dunbar 80 81 Colin Halcrow Windyhill 79 82 Ian Dickson Lundin 79 82 Glen Ballantyne Williamswood 78 83 Alistair Fiddes Deeside 77 84 Iain Stewart Curragh 83 79 David Bunker Nairn Dunbar 82 80 Brian Campbell Ladbrook Park 81 81 Brian Halbert Callander 81 81 Donald Moody Bramford 78 84 Ian Peddie Tulliallan 76 86 Richard Goodale Aberdour 84 79 Tom Nicol Elderslie 83 80 James Kinloch Cardross 80 83 Robert Kerr Uphall 80 83 Ronnie McLennan Turnberry 77 86 John W Johnston Royal Aberdeen 83 81 Neil MacDonald Glenbervie 83 81 David Millar New Club 80 84 Peter Jamieson Cathkin Braes 80 84 Alan MacNaught Colchester 79 85 Mike Robson Kingsknowe 79 85 Tony McIntyre Lundin 86 79 John McDonald Cowglen 83 82 Bert Nicholson Royal Dornoch 81 84 Colin Moir Worksop 81 84 Ken Thomson Brammall Park 79 86 Richard Gray Cowglen 85 81 Alec Ingram New Golf Club 83 83 David Donaldson Glasgow 82 84 Michael Jenkins Duffhouse Royal 81 85 Billy Wallace Strathaven 80 86 Donnie Lindsay Windyhill 79 87 Keith Howie West Kilbride 87 80 John Sim Duffhouse Royal 84 84 Les Fowler Royal Aberdeen 83 85 Tim Hartnet St Andrews 80 88 Alan Nelson Banchory 83 87 Jim Bunting Ballochmyle 81 89 Tom Gray Lanark 88 83 Ian Kerr Kilmacolm 86 85 Brian Highley Buchanan Castle 85 86 Alistair Nicol Troon Portland 83 88 Brian Inglis Archerfield 87 85 Philip Addis Parkstone 85 87 John Campbell West Kilbride 89 84 Phil Costello Hirsel 88 85 Alex Ritchie Bothwell Castle 87 86 Alex Thomson Glasgow 83 90 Robbie Nairn Lochmaben 83 90 Ian Jeen Milngavie 85 89 David Nelson Aboyne 87 88 Lee Bushby Strathmore 85 90 Denis Albutt Royal Dornoch 90 87 Malcolm Sim Grange 88 89 Peter Burns Glasgow 87 91 Alan Chainey North Berwick 94 85 Peter Grey Brunston Castle 86 93 Ian Donaldson Killin 85 94 Charles Brown Auchterarder 91 89 Peter Kinloch Cardross 90 90 Denis McQuade Glenbervie 89 91 Richard Gray Lanark 87 94 Michael Mather Ballater 89 93 David Causon Elderslie 95 89 David Warren North Berwick N/R 82 Ken Goodwin Glenbervie N/R 83 David MacLean Hamilton NR 85 Trevor Bennet Great Barr NR 86 Bill Methven Royal Aberdeen 82 NR Fraser Sharp Boat of Garten 92 NR Gordon Doig Southerness 81 NR Jim Roy Grange 78 NR Jim Watt Edzell 80 NR Kevin Mullins New Club 87 NR David Leighton Northern 79 WD Ian Roughead Glenbervie NR WD L